Saturday, February 28, 1970
THE MAGIC CHRISTIAN. Co-written by Peter Sellers and Terry Southern, based on Southern’s 1959 novel. Music by Ken Thorne. Co-written and directed by Joseph McGrath. Running time: 92 minutes.
AS FAR AS SIR GUY Grand is concerned, the world is in an awful muddle. It’s so full of lead-bottomed traditions, customs and social conventions that nobody appreciates the mystery of life.
An eccentric British millionaire, Sir Guy (Peter Sellers) sets out on a single-minded crusade to create more mystery, determined to outrage society and lead all of its sacred cows to the slaughter.
A single scene from The Magic Christian tells all. Sir Guy is on the moor hunting pheasant. The conversation among the aristocrats turns to the beauty of the clean kill. Of course, agrees Sir Guy, a sudden fanatic gleam in his eye.
Submachine-gun in hand, he leaps forward, flushing the game birds from their nests with a spray of bullets! As they take to the air, he radios range directions to an artillery battery which immediately doffs its camouflage netting and begins to lay down a flak pattern.
Finally, a bird falls to the ground. Instantly, an infantryman appears from the brush and roasts the carcass with a blast from a flamethrower. A chef arranges the charred fowl on a silver platter and presents the dish to Sir Guy, while a marching band plays a salute to his "clean kill.”
For director Joseph McGrath, such excess is typical. One of five directors who worked on 1967’s Casino Royale, McGrath is generally credited with that film’s frantically unfunny “way-out” comedy sequences.
What style he has all seems to have been lifted wholesale from some of the more disciplined young lions of the British cinema, innovators such as Tony Richardson and Richard Lester. To their techniques, McGrath has added little, except the occasional homage to classic lovers (the seven fantasy sequences in 1968’s The Bliss of Mrs. Blossom) or a reference to Eisenstein’s Potemkin (1925) toward the end of The Magic Christian.
McGrath, a former London TV director, shared script writing duties with American satirist Terry Southern (author of the 1959 novel) and comedian Peter Sellers. Their combined movie experience counts for very little in the result.
Like the costly Casino Royale, The Magic Christian is a disjointed collection of intermittently funny sketches. The humour is often fey and occasionally overly English. The routines themselves are inconsistent and give the film as a whole a feeling of incoherence.
The cast is heavily laden with briefly appearing guest stars — among them Richard Attenborough, Laurence Harvey, Christopher Lee, Roman Polanski, Yul Brynner and Raquel Welch — but the main performances are given by Sellers and Ringo Starr. The Beatle drummer plays Sir Guy’s adopted son and conversational sounding board, Youngman. Neither works very hard.
Truth to tell, there’s not a lot to work for. Sir Guy believes that every man has his price. He pays people to make fools of themselves to continually prove his point. Any TV game show can turn the same trick.
Director McGrath could take a few lessons from American underground filmmaker Robert Downey, the man who made 1969’s Putney Swope. A black adman, his Swope performs the ultimate feat. The fools pay him to be put on.
The above is a restored version of a Vancouver Express review by Michael Walsh originally published in 1970. For additional information on this archived material, please visit my FAQ.
Afterword: Joseph McGrath may not have been a major creative talent, but he did have the good luck to be part of a moment of rapid cultural change. A Scots-born TV director, he seems to have worked with every significant British comic talent of the 1960s, a Who’s Who that included Spike Milligan, Peter Cook, Dudley Moore and Peter Sellers, as well as John Clesse and Graham Chapman in the days before Monty Python. Having collaborated with director Richard Lester on his two Beatles features — A Hard Day’s Night (1964), and Help! (1965) — McGrath went on to direct the Fab Four in nine 1965 music videos. It all came together in his third full-length feature, The Magic Christian.
According to its Wikipedia page,
Although McGrath, now 89 and retired, probably has an opinion on the current state of the United Kingdom, I’ve not been able to find any report of it on the Internet. His old friend Ringo Starr, now 79 and living in Los Angeles, has been more forthcoming. “I voted for Brexit,” the former Beatle said in a 2016 interview with Bloomberg News. The European Union is “in shambles,” he added. “Britain should be out and get back on its own feet.” Credited with being the richest former drummer in the world, he joined the aristocracy in 2018, to become Sir Ringo (actually Sir Richard Starkey), an honour conferred upon him by Prince William for his “services to music.”
Anarchy in the U.K.: Today’s British election eve Reeling Back package contains director Joseph McGrath’s 1969 black comedy The Magic Christian, Alan Parker’s rock opera Pink Floyd: The Wall (1982), Peter Webb’s Paul McCartney fantasy Give My Regards To Broad Street, and Alex Cox’s punk rock biography Sid and Nancy (1986).